AIG Insurance Tangle Over Vacant Property Break-In Unravels
AIG Insurance Tangle Over Vacant Property Break-In Unravels
1
A landlord initially seeking compensation of $102,270 for theft and repair costs following a break-in at a vacant commercial property was awarded $45,724 after a protracted insurance dispute with AIG Australia.
The issue revolved around discrepancies over a premium for an unoccupied building.
The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) intervened, reducing the payout by $56,546. This amount corresponds to the difference the landlord would have owed AIG in premiums to insure a building unoccupied for more than 90 consecutive days - an arrangement the landlord neglected, despite receiving clear directives from a broker.
The landlord, with guidance from their broker, had filed a claim last July after criminals gained access through a leased security gate, prompting AIG to refuse the claim due to the structure’s vacant status, which wasn't covered under the policy.
Prior to the unfortunate event, the broker had made the building owner and managing agent aware of the need to refresh AIG of the vacant situation, potentially affecting claims, and the possibility of acquiring extra coverage by adjusting the premium.
Despite the advice, the owner failed to take action, leading to AIG being notified about the vacancy only post-theft. AFCA indicated that AIG would likely have underwritten the unoccupancy risk had they been told, and determined it fair to authorize the claim - factoring in the supplemental premium and other conditions like an excess charge.
Section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act became pivotal, with AFCA stating that the breach pertained to not informing the insurer of the decision to leave the property vacant beyond 90 days without seeking written permission - not merely the fact that the premises were left empty.
An AFCA official explained, “I am not of the view that the complainant’s failure to request the insurer’s written consent ... can reasonably be regarded as being capable of causing or contributing to the malicious damage and theft event.”
They emphasized, “The insurer cannot refuse to pay the claim by reason only of the post-contractual act, that is, by reason only of the complainant’s failure to seek its written consent. The insurer is, however, entitled to reduce its liability to the extent that it has been prejudiced.”
AFCA specified that AIG had not proved the extent of its disadvantage equaled its ability to completely dismiss its liability under the policy. Instead, AFCA accepted that the liability compared to the additional premium deemed appropriate if the vacancy had been disclosed.
Arguments suggesting partial occupancy, due to daily visits from a property manager and maintenance by contractors, were rejected, as was the claim that it was unjust to deny coverage because the theft transpired over a weekend when the premises would be unoccupied even if tenanted.
This information originally featured in an article in Insurance News Magazine.
Published:Friday, 1st Nov 2024 Source: Paige Estritori
Australian insurer QBE has reported a significant increase in net profit for the first half of fiscal 2025, reaching $997 million. This figure surpasses both the previous year's profit of $777 million and market estimates of $839.39 million. The impressive performance is attributed to robust premium growth in North America and international markets, coupled with lower-than-expected claims. - read more
Suncorp, a leading Australian insurer, has reported an 8% increase in full-year cash earnings, reaching A$1.49 billion for the year ending June 30. This performance surpasses analyst expectations of A$1.47 billion and is attributed to improved underlying insurance margins and a 16% increase in net investment returns, totaling A$766 million. - read more
Insurance Australia Group (IAG) has reported a significant 91% increase in net profit for the first half of the fiscal year, reaching $778 million. This substantial growth is attributed to favourable weather conditions and strategic business operations. Despite a general easing of inflationary pressures, IAG's CEO, Nick Hawkins, has indicated that insurance premiums are expected to continue rising, albeit at a slower pace. - read more
Whether you're a carpenter, electrician, plumber, or any other type of tradesperson, your work is essential to keeping homes and businesses running smoothly. But have you ever thought about how important insurance is for your trade business? - read more
For tradespeople, tools and equipment are the backbone of their daily operations. From basic hand tools to advanced machinery, having the right gear is crucial for delivering quality work and maintaining efficiency. - read more
Public liability insurance is a type of coverage designed to protect you in the event that a member of the public is injured or their property is damaged because of your business activities. It's essential for tradespeople whose everyday work involves interacting with clients and the public—or working in environments where accidents could happen. - read more
Dictionary
Whole Life Insurance
noun
A type of life insurance that provides coverage for the insured's entire lifetime, with a savings component that builds cash value.
