AFCA Upholds Pause on QBE Claim but Dismisses Fraud Allegation

2

The issue arose when the director reported a crash involving his Audi and another vehicle in June 2023. QBE doubted the legitimacy of the claim, citing discrepancies in the director's account and pointing to questionable financial motives due to the Audi's insurance coverage of $25,800. Additionally, the director's refusal to supply bank and phone records and inconsistencies in his timeline further raised concerns.

Furthermore, a mechanical engineer's report suggested that the damage did not align with a vehicular collision, but rather implied contact with a stationary object like a pole. Nonetheless, the director challenged both the engineer’s findings and the relevance of QBE’s requests, given that the third party had already admitted fault in the incident.

After examining the case, AFCA concluded that evidence was insufficient to prove the fraud. The director's consistent income and an assessment by the insurer’s own evaluator, suggesting the damage matched the reported accident, weakened QBE's claims of deceit.

AFCA has instructed QBE to reinstate the director’s insurance policy, reopening the claim upon submission of the required bank and phone records. These documents are deemed crucial by AFCA for thoroughly assessing the claim's background and any financial incentives.

In a separate complaint, the director opposed QBE's decision to auction off the Audi for $900, claiming he hadn't authorized the sale and that the price fell short of the vehicle's estimated salvage value of $1500. However, AFCA sided with QBE, stating that the director was adequately informed and given considerable time to retrieve the vehicle. No compensation for the auction sale discrepancy was deemed necessary, though the director would be entitled to these proceeds if the claim ultimately gets denied.

The ruling emphasizes the critical role of transparency and thorough documentation in insurance claims. As the case progresses, both parties will need to adhere to AFCA's directions to ensure a fair resolution.

Published:Wednesday, 21st May 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

AFCA Upholds Insurer's Decision on Claimant's Non-Disclosure 12 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori A recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) supported Auto & General's decision to deny a motor policyholder's claim after a crash. The decision stemmed from the policyholder's failure to disclose a driving-related good behaviour bond, despite his claims of a learning disability affecting his understanding of the policy's inquiries. - read more

Insurer Ordered to Cover Restaurant Arson Despite Director's Unrevealed Criminal Record 12 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori In a recent decision, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) directed insurer QBE to honour an arson claim for a restaurant, despite the owner's failure to disclose prior criminal convictions during the policy's inception. The restaurant, which operates from a leased location, suffered extensive damage due to an arson attack on August 2 of last year, halting its business operations. While the arsonist was apprehended, QBE initially denied the claim, citing non-disclosure of the director's criminal history. - read more

Insurance Sector Reports $1 Billion Profit Amidst Household Strain 11 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori The insurance industry secured a net profit after tax of $1.11 billion in the March quarter, with major contributions from insurers at $990 million and reinsurers at $123 million, as revealed by the latest data from the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority. The insurance service result, a key indicator of underwriting success, reached $1.32 billion during this period, while investment returns added an impressive $1.18 billion. - read more